Nigh On Perfect Barlows

 

We live in a golden age of manufacturing. Between the knowledge and capability supplied by science & technology combined with the oversite of a zillion observers on the WWW, it’s hard to make a bad product and stay in business very long. Of course, that doesn’t keep us from arguing about what’s the best. With that in mind, I would like to point out a few Barlow knives that are almost perfect, knives most anyone would be very happy to own. I’m going to start with a high bar and work my way up:

My first entry for consideration is the “Rough Ryder Reserve Red Jigged Bone Original Barlow Folding Knife RRR017RB.” This knife almost has it all, handsome red bone handles, one of the best blades for all round use, the spearpoint, and sturdy D2 steel. The action and feel of the thing screams quality. Any flaws? Just one, it only has a single blade. I can go a long way on a two bladed knife (one larger, the other smaller), before I have to deploy every folder’s more capable brother, the Victorinox. Of course, I knew it only had one blade when I bought it, but it seemed good enough to ignore that fact, and it is. One would be hard pressed to point out a better single blade Barlow.

May be the best looking traditional out there.

Two is the “RoseCraft Beaver Creek Barlow RCT006.” I think Rosecraft’s bourbon bone handles were a real homerun with most folks and they wrap some truly grand knives. I like the way Rosecraft can work within a traditional knife’s parameters and still come up with something that looks unique. Once our plumber asked me if I had a knife he could use. I handed him my Rosecraft Barlow, he looked distinctly unimpressed. Later, he asked me, “Do you still got that razor knife on you?” D2 will get you through. So what’s wrong with this one, besides the single blade? Nothing really, I’d just rather it was a different blade, I’m not crazy about the sheepsfoot.

A real looker.

Which brings us to the “Rosecraft Otter Creek Barlow RCT020.” So very close, I really wanted this one to be the best Barlow ever, and it almost is. The sandalwood handles serve to show off a great knife with a practical D2 Clip Point blade, and a front bolster with an otter paw print, just for giggles. So what’s wrong with this one, Mr. Picky Guy? The nail nick is too far back, I feel like a shorter swedge would have made for an easier opening blade. If you have occasional trouble with nail nicks, I’d look at this one in person before you buy. It could have been the GOAT.

Coulda been a contender.

This may raise some hackles but the “Rough Rider Bluegill Barlow Jigged Bone Folding Knife RR2632” and many of the other RR Barlows are nigh on perfect. Preserving that classic style, these two bladed 440 Barlows do everything a Barlow should do and do it in style. This is the point where I’m supposed to say it’s great “for its price.” I’m not going to say that, these are objectively good knives. (If you don’t like the low price, you can send me some money every time you buy one, that way we’ll both feel better.) Flaws? Just one: The models without nail nicks on the opposite sides can be very difficult to deploy. I hear they are changing that, but they won’t update the catalog pictures, so you’re buying at your own risk. (You know, once you buy a digital camera, the pictures are free.) I think anything new, like the Bluegill is a safe bet. And really, “you need a magnacut Barlow?” Why?

Named for another tiny powerhouse, the freshwater bluegill.

Finally, and this one may really be The Perfect Barlow. The Bear & Son Yellow Delrin Barlow with stainless steel blades is my nominee for perfection: classic scales, two 440 blades, and made in America. So what could be wrong about that? Just that I bought one from Red Hill Cutlery, about a hear and a half ago and haven’t seen any since. That may have been the last USA made Barlow for under 20 bucks in history. Good news though, the carbon steel version is readily available, though I can’t call it perfect because I have never used one. I suspect it may be the real deal.

Where is that bear? This is the carbon steel version.
The stainless model has a B&S medallion and "Barlow" written across the front bolster.

 

The Neo-Barlow: What Hath God Wrought?

 

The Finch 1929

The classic American Barlow knife has a handle that’s about 3 ½ inches long, a long top bolster, and a subtle teardrop shape. A typical modern knife has a locking blade, a fast-opening mechanism, and a pocket clip. And never the twain shall meet, until lately. Or should I say finally. The modern and traditional knife worlds are coming together thanks to some innovative designers and some willing customers. If you are anything like me, you’ve been waiting for this. Traditional knives look great but can be, at times, inconvenient. On the other hand, modern knives have great conveniences but are ugly as sin.

There is no better example of a neo-Barlow than the Finch 1929. It has the right look, the right dimensions, and taking a bold leap into the Space Age, a pocket clip. It’s also a flipper with a locking blade. Heavens forefend. They don’t call it a Barlow, probably because they don’t want to get mired down in endless questions of genuine authenticity, but rest assured, it’s a Barlow. Come to think of it, if the guy who invented the Barlow had thought to himself, "wait, this is too modern for 1670," we never would have gotten such a grand old design to begin with.

Are there any drawbacks to this new design? None that I can see. I’ve been carrying one for months and it does everything my other 12 Barlows can do, but it’s faster to open and easier to find in my pocket. I do think the opening mechanism on a traditional slipjoint will probably last longer, long enough to leave to my grandson, but he can buy his own knife. Heck, by that time, they will probably be cuttings things with tiny lightsabers from the Smokey Mountain Laser Works.

The 1929 is a bit on the pricey side. I bought mine last year for $125.oo, but there are other, less expensive neo-Barlows out there. There is the Smith & Wesson “Executive Barlow” that the Amazon blurb says is for “Outdoor, Tactical, & Survival,” but I wouldn’t go that far. It is, however, a swanky little Barlow with, hold your breath now, assisted opening. "O brave new world!" It’s also dirt cheap, around 23 bucks.

Smith & Wesson Executive Barlow

Then there is the  Rosecraft Blades Castorea which is nothing more than a big ol’ Grandaddy Barlow that flips, locks, and pockets with the best of them. It sells for a mere twenty dollars. Yup, Rosecraft quality for a couple of sawbucks.

Rosecraft Castorea

There are even new Barlows out there with modern looks and old fashion mechanisms, though I’m not sure why. It reminds me of the time when Sarah Bernhardt, a famous beauty, met George Bernard Shaw, a famous intellect. She suggested they combine their glorious attributes by having a child. He answered, “But what if the child were born with my looks and your brain?” So, I will leave those recommendations to someone else.

Rough Ryder Bluegill Barlow

     

Courtesy SMKW

     For the past six months, I’ve been looking for the perfect workplace Barlow. It’s replacing a no name Barlow I bought when I was ten. The knives were competing with nostalgia and that’s a tough benchmark. 

     I bought ten knives, from Rough Ryder, Case, Bear & Sons, and Rosecraft. Almost all of them were good, some great, but none of them were quite right. Then came the Bluegill, I ordered it before they even had a picture of it up, so my expectations were vague. On initial inspection, I was thrilled, this was my perfect work Barlow. 

     Was it the best Barlow I had purchased, objectively speaking? No, that honor would go to the Rosecraft and the Rough Ryder Reserve. Did it look the most like the one I had as a kid? No, that would be of the sawcut bone variety, which I haven’t gotten yet. But it was a perfect Rough Ryder Barlow, great pull, nail nicks facing opposite directions (a must on Rough Ryder Barlows), and great looking green, thick, jigged bone handle slabs (I don’t know what to call that kind of jigging but I think of it as “rustic”), and two, not one, but two blades. I use the pen blade a lot at work. The construction was solid. 

The theme didn’t hurt. Back in the day, we kids would sneak up to a local pond, teeming with bluegill, and see if we could catch any. We caught quite a few, before the owners found us there and kicked us out. It usually took them a week or two. The pond was overstocked and we didn’t know how to filet, so eating those little fish was more like picking crabs, but we had fun. 

     Practically speaking I haven’t used the knife much, it’s brand new. But I did use it to cut up a ham steak. It was a thick steak made by Frick’s. I cut it into 8 strips and made 8 cubes from each, it was smooth sailing, all slicing, no sawing. I was pleasantly surprised at how well the clip point blade cut off the rind, sticking very close with the loss of very little meat. My dogs were a little disappointed. Performance-wise, it cut better than my paring knives (Victorinox, Opinel), but not quite as good as my D2 RR Reserve Barlow, which goes through meat like a lightsaber. 

     The knife’s specs (RR2632) are classic Barlow, 3 3/8” long, 440 Stainless steel blades, etc. If I could only have one knife, well, it would be of the Swiss Army variety, but if I could only own two knives, my second choice would be a Barlow, a Bluegill Barlow.